Skip to main content
Soventro

Review speaker proposals and decide

Set up reviewers and a scorecard, use blind review, handle conflicts of interest, then accept, waitlist or decline proposals.
From the video guide The program, with its transcript.

Reviewers score each proposal on your scorecard. You see their scores and comments side by side, then accept, waitlist or decline. Accepting turns the proposal into a speaker and a draft session in one step.

Add reviewers

  1. Give each reviewer the Speaker reviewer role (or a role that includes reviewing) under Settings → Team. See Team members and roles.
  2. On Program → Call for speakers, select Reviewers. Everyone who can review appears here.
  3. For each reviewer, fill in their Company and Declared conflicts: companies, email addresses, or domains like @acme.com, separated by commas.

Nobody can be assigned a proposal from their own company, their own address or a declared conflict, including any co-author's. If you add a conflict later, undecided proposals that now conflict lose that reviewer and any score they gave. Your team keeps these details rather than the reviewers themselves, so nobody can test names to find out who wrote a blind proposal.

Set up the scorecard

On Program → Call for speakers → Settings, under Scorecard:

  • Each line is a criterion that reviewers score from 1 to 5. New calls start with Relevance to this audience (weight 2), Quality of the proposal (weight 2) and Original thinking (weight 1).
  • Weight runs from 1 to 5. A weight of 2 counts twice as much as a weight of 1.
  • Clear a line to remove it. You can have up to 12 criteria.

Blind review

Tick Hide who wrote each proposal from reviewers to hide the speaker's name, company, job title and bio, and remove their name, email and company from the proposal text. Co-authors are hidden the same way. You can also tick your own questions to hide from blind reviewers; email and phone questions are always hidden.

Removing names from the text is done as well as it can be, and reviewers are told so. A speaker can still give themselves away in other words. People who manage the program always see everything.

Assign reviewers to a proposal

  1. Open a proposal from Program → Call for speakers.
  2. In the Reviews card, choose someone under Add a reviewer and select Add reviewer.

The proposal moves to In review. Each reviewer shows as Waiting, Scored or Recused. You can select Remove on a reviewer who hasn't scored yet; once they've scored or recused, their record stays.

How reviewers score

Reviewers find their proposals under Program → My reviews, marked To score, Scored or Recused.

  1. Open a proposal and read it.
  2. Under Your scores, choose a score for every criterion.
  3. Add a Comment if you like. Managers see it; other reviewers don't.
  4. Select Submit my scores. They can change them later with Update my scores until the proposal is decided.

Reviewers see other reviewers' combined score only after they've submitted their own.

Conflict of interest: a reviewer who realizes they know the speaker can select Recuse myself, with an optional reason. Any score they gave is removed, they stop seeing the proposal, and they can't be assigned to it again.

Read the results

On the proposal, the Reviews card shows the weighted average out of 5 and each reviewer's scores and comments. The proposals list shows how many have scored and the average for each. Recused and unfinished reviews don't count toward the average.

Record a decision

In the Decision card:

  1. Choose Decision: Accept, Waitlist or Decline.
  2. When accepting, choose the Speaker: link to a speaker already at the event (one with the same email is suggested), or Create a new speaker from this proposal.
  3. Enter a Reason. It's required, for your team's records, and never sent to the speaker.
  4. Optionally add a Message to the speaker. It's added to the decision email.
  5. Select Record decision and email speaker.

Once a proposal is decided, reviews close.

What accepting does

  • The speaker is added to Program → Speakers, hidden from the website, with their details from the proposal. Co-authors are added as hidden speakers too, matched by email if they're already at the event.
  • A draft session is added to the agenda with the talk's title and description, hidden and marked Needs a time. Give it a time and room on Program → Agenda, then untick Hide from the website.
  • Each speaker gets the tasks from What accepted speakers are asked for.
  • The speaker who sent the proposal gets an acceptance email with a private link to their speaker page.
  • Each co-author gets their own acceptance email, with a private link to their own speaker page. Co-authors are emailed once per proposal, and aren't emailed if you waitlist or decline. The proposal's History shows each "Co-author emailed" entry.

When a proposal has co-authors, the button reads Record decision and email speakers. Anything you write in Message to the speaker goes in the co-authors' emails too.

Recording the same decision twice never creates a second speaker, session or email. If you decline after accepting, the speaker and session stay in place, since they may already be on the agenda; remove them on the Speakers and Agenda tabs if they should go.

Tips

  • Use Waitlist for strong talks you might need if a speaker drops out. You can accept them later.
  • Agree on what each score means with your reviewers before they start.

Still need help?

Email the Soventro team and a person will get back to you during business hours (US Eastern).

info@soventro.com